Tuesday, November 21, 2006

In our hobby, we are turning natural selection upside down. Instead of one frog eating his brothers and sisters, we let them all live. Then we get rid of all the predators, (over)feed them, relentlessly clean their water, and give them a stable temperature to develop. We make it so the vast majority of eggs laid in our hobby turn into frogs that are bred and produce offspring for this hobby.

I think there are a lot of frogs in our hobby that shouldn’t have made the cut. We are watering down the frogs we have by continually adding weak frogs into the system. I have set a few guidelines for my breeding practices in an effort to get rid of some weak frogs while still maintaining the supply I need to make a living.

First off, I have stopped using Methylene Blue on my eggs. If the egg molds then it molds. I’m not babying eggs anymore.

Secondly, I’m not doing any water changes. And I don’t miss it at all. Could our constant water changes be affecting our frogs in the same way too sterile conditions lead to allergies in humans?

Finally, I have created a slope system (see Breeding) where only frogs with the strongest front legs survive. SLS comes in varying degrees, so I want to cull the frogs that show any signs. Could easy access out of the water be a contributing factor to SLS in the fact that frogs don’t need strong legs to get out of our water, so they don’t develop strong front legs?

I welcome your feedback.

6 comments:

wax32 said...

Hmmm. gets me thinking! I think you might just be on to something.

Chuck Powell said...

Congratulations. I've been arguing this for years. I don't "baby" my eggs to frogs at all. If they can't make it they die. Oh well. I wish more people would realize that it may be good for them in the short run, but its not good for the frogs or the hobby in the long run.

Best,

Chuck

Chuck Powell said...

Congratulations. I've been arguing this for years. I don't "baby" my eggs to frogs at all. If they can't make it they die. Oh well. I wish more people would realize that it may be good for them in the short run, but its not good for the frogs or the hobby in the long run.

Best,

Chuck

W.K. said...

You should post this on DB Josh. I asked a similar question and got no responses. I think our minimizing every threat possible goes allow inferior animals to survive that in the wild would not. I would not want to buy a frog that I knew had to be coddled to survive. I am glad you are doing what you do.

Erik said...

Yeah, selective pressure is removed when we feed frogs disabled insects and do everything we can to keep them alive.

Hobbyists who look at their pets and imagine them repopulating extinct or troubled wild populations are living in LaLa Land.

Unknown said...

Natural selection becomes unnatural selection as soon as we get involved in selecting which frogs breed.

The same happens with heirloom flowers. People tend to select what they like, multiply several generations and you have a variation of that heirloom.